| Fowler's Toad | Anaxyrus | fowleri | | 1 | Bufonidae | Anura | Amphibia | Animalia |
| Cope's Gray Treefrog | Hyla | chrysoscelis | | 1 | Hylidae | Anura | Amphibia | Animalia |
| American Goldfinch | Spinus | tristis | | 1 | Fringillidae | Passeriformes | Aves | Animalia |
| Eyed Click Beetle | Alaus | oculatus | | 2 | Elateridae | Coleoptera | Insecta | Animalia |
| Eastern Hercules Beetle | Dynastes | tityus | | 1 | Scarabaeidae | Coleoptera | Insecta | Animalia |
| Japanese Beetle | Popillia | japonica | | 2 | Scarabaeidae | Coleoptera | Insecta | Animalia |
| No Common Name | Efferia | sp. | | 2 | Asilidae | Diptera | Insecta | Animalia |
| Golden-backed Snipe Fly | Chrysopilus | thoracicus | | 4 | Rhagionidae | Diptera | Insecta | Animalia |
| No Common Name | Delphinia | picta | | 1 | Ulidiidae | Diptera | Insecta | Animalia |
| Witch Hazel Cone Gall Aphid | Hormaphis | hamamelidis | | 2 | Aphididae | Hemiptera | Insecta | Animalia |
| No Common Name | Graphocephala | versuta | | 1 | Cicadellidae | Hemiptera | Insecta | Animalia |
| Swamp Cicada | Neotibicen | tibicen | | 3 | Cicadidae | Hemiptera | Insecta | Animalia |
| Eastern Scissor Grinder Cicada | Neotibicen | winnemanna | | 1 | Cicadidae | Hemiptera | Insecta | Animalia |
| Spotted Lanternfly | Lycorma | delicatula | | 2 | Fulgoridae | Hemiptera | Insecta | Animalia |
| Small Milkweed Bug | Lygaeus | kalmii | | 1 | Lygaeidae | Hemiptera | Insecta | Animalia |
| Large Milkweed Bug | Oncopeltus | fasciatus | | 4 | Lygaeidae | Hemiptera | Insecta | Animalia |
| No Common Name | Stictocephala | brevitylus | | 1 | Membracidae | Hemiptera | Insecta | Animalia |
| Harlequin Bug | Murgantia | histrionica | | 1 | Pentatomidae | Hemiptera | Insecta | Animalia |
| Two-spotted Bumble Bee | Bombus | bimaculatus | | 1 | Apidae | Hymenoptera | Insecta | Animalia |
| Northern Carpenter Bee | Xylocopa | virginica | | 1 | Apidae | Hymenoptera | Insecta | Animalia |
| Pipe Organ Mud Dauber | Trypoxylon | politum | | 1 | Crabronidae | Hymenoptera | Insecta | Animalia |
| No Common Name | Osmia | taurus | | 1 | Megachilidae | Hymenoptera | Insecta | Animalia |
| Milkweed Tussock Moth | Euchaetes | egle | | 1 | Erebidae | Lepidoptera | Insecta | Animalia |
| Giant Leopard Moth | Hypercompe | scribonia | | 3 | Erebidae | Lepidoptera | Insecta | Animalia |
| Lunate Zale Moth | Zale | lunata | | 1 | Erebidae | Lepidoptera | Insecta | Animalia |
| Fall Cankerworm Moth | Alsophila | pometaria | | 1 | Geometridae | Lepidoptera | Insecta | Animalia |
| Pale Beauty Moth | Campaea | perlata | | 1 | Geometridae | Lepidoptera | Insecta | Animalia |
| Tulip-tree Beauty Moth | Epimecis | hortaria | | 1 | Geometridae | Lepidoptera | Insecta | Animalia |
| Brown-shaded Gray Moth | Iridopsis | defectaria | | 1 | Geometridae | Lepidoptera | Insecta | Animalia |
| Juniper Geometer Moth | Patalene | olyzonaria | | 1 | Geometridae | Lepidoptera | Insecta | Animalia |
| Wavy-lined Emerald Moth | Synchlora | aerata | | 1 | Geometridae | Lepidoptera | Insecta | Animalia |
| Sachem | Atalopedes | huron | | 1 | Hesperiidae | Lepidoptera | Insecta | Animalia |
| Silver-spotted Skipper | Epargyreus | clarus | | 1 | Hesperiidae | Lepidoptera | Insecta | Animalia |
| Horace's Duskywing | Erynnis | horatius | | 1 | Hesperiidae | Lepidoptera | Insecta | Animalia |
| Skiff Moth | Prolimacodes | badia | | 1 | Limacodidae | Lepidoptera | Insecta | Animalia |
| Eastern Tailed-Blue | Cupido | comyntas orientalis | | 1 | Lycaenidae | Lepidoptera | Insecta | Animalia |
| Brown-hooded Owlet Moth | Cucullia | convexipennis | | 1 | Noctuidae | Lepidoptera | Insecta | Animalia |
| Viceroy | Limenitis | archippus | | 1 | Nymphalidae | Lepidoptera | Insecta | Animalia |
| Red-spotted Purple | Limenitis | arthemis astyanax | | 1 | Nymphalidae | Lepidoptera | Insecta | Animalia |
| Red Admiral | Vanessa | atalanta | | 2 | Nymphalidae | Lepidoptera | Insecta | Animalia |
| Zebra Swallowtail | Eurytides | marcellus | | 1 | Papilionidae | Lepidoptera | Insecta | Animalia |
| Eastern Tiger Swallowtail | Pterourus | glaucus | | 1 | Papilionidae | Lepidoptera | Insecta | Animalia |
| Sleepy Orange | Abaeis | nicippe | | 1 | Pieridae | Lepidoptera | Insecta | Animalia |
| Cabbage White | Pieris | rapae | | 1 | Pieridae | Lepidoptera | Insecta | Animalia |
| Luna Moth | Actias | luna | | 2 | Saturniidae | Lepidoptera | Insecta | Animalia |
| Rosy Maple Moth | Dryocampa | rubicunda | | 1 | Saturniidae | Lepidoptera | Insecta | Animalia |
| Catalpa Sphinx | Ceratomia | catalpae | | 1 | Sphingidae | Lepidoptera | Insecta | Animalia |
| Pandorus Sphinx | Eumorpha | pandorus | | 1 | Sphingidae | Lepidoptera | Insecta | Animalia |
| Ailanthus Webworm Moth | Atteva | aurea | | 1 | Yponomeutidae | Lepidoptera | Insecta | Animalia |
| Carolina Mantis | Stagmomantis | carolina | | 2 | Mantidae | Mantodea | Insecta | Animalia |
| Ebony Jewelwing | Calopteryx | maculata | | 5 | Calopterygidae | Odonata | Insecta | Animalia |
| Slaty Skimmer | Libellula | incesta | | 1 | Libellulidae | Odonata | Insecta | Animalia |
| Widow Skimmer | Libellula | luctuosa | | 1 | Libellulidae | Odonata | Insecta | Animalia |
| Needham's Skimmer | Libellula | needhami | | 1 | Libellulidae | Odonata | Insecta | Animalia |
| Blue Dasher | Pachydiplax | longipennis | | 1 | Libellulidae | Odonata | Insecta | Animalia |
| Eastern Amberwing | Perithemis | tenera | | 1 | Libellulidae | Odonata | Insecta | Animalia |
| Common Whitetail | Plathemis | lydia | | 2 | Libellulidae | Odonata | Insecta | Animalia |
| Differential Grasshopper | Melanoplus | differentialis | | 1 | Acrididae | Orthoptera | Insecta | Animalia |
| Red-legged Grasshopper | Melanoplus | femurrubrum | | 1 | Acrididae | Orthoptera | Insecta | Animalia |
| Short-winged Meadow Katydid | Conocephalus | brevipennis | | 3 | Tettigoniidae | Orthoptera | Insecta | Animalia |
| Modest Katydid | Montezumina | modesta | | 1 | Tettigoniidae | Orthoptera | Insecta | Animalia |
| Common Five-lined Skink | Plestiodon | fasciatus | | 1 | Scincidae | Squamata | Reptilia | Animalia |
| Broad-headed Skink | Plestiodon | laticeps | | 1 | Scincidae | Squamata | Reptilia | Animalia |
| Eastern Box Turtle | Terrapene | carolina carolina | | 1 | Emydidae | Testudines | Reptilia | Animalia |
| Common Persimmon | Diospyros | virginiana | | 1 | Ebenaceae | Ebenales | Magnoliopsida | Plantae |
| Virginia Saltmarsh Mallow | Kosteletzkya | pentacarpos | | 1 | Malvaceae | Malvales | Magnoliopsida | Plantae |
| Mayapple | Podophyllum | peltatum | | 1 | Berberidaceae | Ranunculales | Magnoliopsida | Plantae |
| Oak Haircap Moss | Polytrichum | ohioense | | 1 | Polytrichaceae | Polytrichales | Polytrichopsida | Plantae |